[Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
- blueradish
- Posts: 130
- Joined: Fri Feb 06, 2015 6:30 pm
- Name: blueradish
- Location: Canada
- Contact:
[Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
Just received my Stuckx Rock “Yell”, thought I’d throw up a review. I don’t do these often since most watches have been reviewed, but being this is a new model, I thought it was appropriate. I have not been solicited by Stuckx to review this watch, I actually purchased and own this piece.
Fit/Wearability – (9/10)
Fantastic! Considering the watch comes in at a towering 27mm tall it wears extremely comfy. The crown is well thought out and nicely placed so as to avoid diggin into the wrist. At 143gr it isn’t super light but not overly heavy either. One would think the weight/height ratio would make this a top heavy watch, but that is not the case. I find no difference wearing this diver vs a traditional one. As one would imagine, there is an increased likelihood of bumping the watch against doors, etc due to the height. What I found interesting is that I naturally found myself being aware of this and avoided any potential issues.
The only issue I had with the fit was an aesthetic one. The case is shaped to match the contour of one’s wrist. This concept works great when there is no strap installed. However, with a strap the case is raised off the wrist and the curved shape of the case looks slightly out of place.
Finish – (10/10)
If you followed Stephan and his crew on Facebook then you know they were painstakingly careful with attention to detail. Sending back samples from the suppliers many times until the parts were just right. It should be noted that boutique watch manufacturers do not typically get the most attention from suppliers as their volumes are much lower than the big boys. Happy that Stuckx developed good relationships with suppliers and kept open communication with its backers in order to take the extra time required to get this one perfect.
Case – (10/10)
My version is a blasted finish and it is stunning, no imperfections, a beautiful mid grey colour, no sharp edges, bezel fits perfectly. There was a lot of thought put into the design of this case and they really did achieve an “outside the box” look that isn’t seen anywhere else.
Dial – (10/10)
Besides the case and overall design this is truly where the Rock shines. Based on Facebook updates, Stephan and his crew accepted no shortcuts or imperfections in this department. It is intricate yet simple with a stunning 3D design that will not disappoint. What I appreciate most is that they did not impose a huge gaudy namesake on the dial. It is a simple, clean Stuckx logo void of any text. Nothing worse that feeling like you’re a mobile billboard for some of these watchmakers.
Lume – (10/10)
As far as the lume goes, they don’t disappoint in this area. Brilliant C3 Luminova makes the dial and bezel shine, the hands literally look like they are lightsabres imposing their power onto the dial to make themselves standout like a Vegas billboard. They even found a way to slap some lume under the bezel between 12 & 4. While understandably not as bright as the indices or bezel markers, it is a nice touch that shows how much effort they put into this piece.
Bezel – (9/10)
While I would have preferred a nice matte bezel to match the whole package of the blasted case and matte dial, the move to go sapphire was solid. When Stuckx decided to move to the upgraded Sapphire bezel I immediately cringed when I saw the pics. I really do not like anything glossy on my watches, I find it cheapens the appearance. However, the sheen of the sapphire, while glossy, really only shows in bright light making for a smashing overall appearance. Bezel has smooth rotation and lines up nicely at 12.
Strap – (7/10)
I really don’t think any watchmaker can win in this department. There is no one utopian strap or strap system for everyone. In fact when I look at the options Stuckx faced, I think they did ok. Trying to decide between 20mm, 22mm, 24mm, fixed or open lugs and then the choice of rubber, nylon, leather combined with Nato, RAF, Zulu, 2pc standard.
The Stuckx strap is soft but sturdy, definitely comfy on the wrist with enough holes to adjust nicely but does feel somewhat cheap. You can tell they put care and effort into designing the straps aesthetics from the stitching colour matched to the respective watch down to the nicely stamped Stuckx logo. Thickness is perfect for comfort and to avoid bulkiness on the wrist. However, the one area that was a real swing and miss for me was the polished hardware against a blasted case. I know it’s a minor detail but imo strap hardware should always match or compliment the case. I do understand economies of scale for the boutique makers result in them having to make these types of decisions. The aftermarket for 24mm Nato/RAF, Zulu straps is somewhat limited in terms of selection compared to the 20mm, 22mm availability. That being said I applaud Stuckx decision to go with the beefier 24mm as opposed to the industry common 20 or 22mm. There is nothing worse than a nice beefy timepiece that is complimented with a dinky little girly 20mm strap. Lastly, while Stuckx did offer a nylon option for an additional fee, I would have preferred to have the choice between leather or nylon or ideally a rubber strap. In my opinion a dive watch should always come with rubber or nylon. I want to be able to jump in the water as soon as I open the package. I love leather on my divers but only when I am wearing it around casually.
Bottom line I don’t know that there was a perfect strap/lug option. Everyone has different preferences and I’m happy they stuck with an outside the box design to keep this a very unique piece.
Packaging/Presentation – (9/10)
Very nicely designed with some thoughtful touches. A convenience flap on the front makes it easy to remove the watchbox from the outer carton. The warranty card is tucked into the lid, nice cushion to hold the watch in place. Lift up the top panel to find a parts bin for additional straps, buckles and tools.
Service – (10/10)
At the time of this writing I have not experienced after-sales service. However, the pre-sales has been nothing short of top-notch. Stuckx does not use the traditional email communication to keep customers informed, bur rather chose to keep us posted thru Facebook. I have never experienced this style of customer updates but it was fantastic. It allowed customers to post pictures as they received watches, questions to be asked and answered and my inbox to be less clogged. One thing for sure is that Stephan busted his balls getting these orders out before Christmas and he was successful. Mine was delivered at 10am Christmas Eve morning. More impressive is that shortly after I received my shipping notification, Stephan sent me a personal email informing me that the alternative strap I ordered with my watch would be follow via regular mail as he shipped the watches from a location other than the shop and only had the stock colour on hand. That’s how you keep customers people. Thanks Stephan!
Bottom Line - (9/10)
A standing ovation please. A fresh new boutique watch company that comes from blood, sweat and tears. A stellar “outside of the box” design and features give customers a one of a kind timepiece that stands up and demands attention on the wrist.
Pros –
24mm lug width
Creative “out of the box” design
Gorgeous fit/finish
Stunning presence on the wrist
Comfortable for a daily wearer
Company communication
Cons –
Polished strap hardware
Should come with choice of leather or nylon
Faux wrist curvature look
Specs (as per Stuckx website)
- Titanium grade 2 lug-less case in blasted finish
- Lug-to-lug 52mm
- 44.8 mm diameter at the top
- 21mm high from case back to sapphire top
- 1000m Water resistance
- Swiss ETA 2824 automatic movement
- C3 Luminova on hands & indices
- Sapphire bezel insert with C3 Luminova markers underneath
- 6mm thick sapphire crystal with AR coating (inside)
- 4mm thick screw-in type case back
- 120 clicks uni-directional bezel
- Leather Zulu/Nato up to 3 mm thickness will fit
- Watch comes in a luxury watch box
- 24 Month warranty
Had a little fun making up some new straps for casual wear. I thought the yellow would prove difficult, but some of the extreme contrasts actually work.
Fit/Wearability – (9/10)
Fantastic! Considering the watch comes in at a towering 27mm tall it wears extremely comfy. The crown is well thought out and nicely placed so as to avoid diggin into the wrist. At 143gr it isn’t super light but not overly heavy either. One would think the weight/height ratio would make this a top heavy watch, but that is not the case. I find no difference wearing this diver vs a traditional one. As one would imagine, there is an increased likelihood of bumping the watch against doors, etc due to the height. What I found interesting is that I naturally found myself being aware of this and avoided any potential issues.
The only issue I had with the fit was an aesthetic one. The case is shaped to match the contour of one’s wrist. This concept works great when there is no strap installed. However, with a strap the case is raised off the wrist and the curved shape of the case looks slightly out of place.
Finish – (10/10)
If you followed Stephan and his crew on Facebook then you know they were painstakingly careful with attention to detail. Sending back samples from the suppliers many times until the parts were just right. It should be noted that boutique watch manufacturers do not typically get the most attention from suppliers as their volumes are much lower than the big boys. Happy that Stuckx developed good relationships with suppliers and kept open communication with its backers in order to take the extra time required to get this one perfect.
Case – (10/10)
My version is a blasted finish and it is stunning, no imperfections, a beautiful mid grey colour, no sharp edges, bezel fits perfectly. There was a lot of thought put into the design of this case and they really did achieve an “outside the box” look that isn’t seen anywhere else.
Dial – (10/10)
Besides the case and overall design this is truly where the Rock shines. Based on Facebook updates, Stephan and his crew accepted no shortcuts or imperfections in this department. It is intricate yet simple with a stunning 3D design that will not disappoint. What I appreciate most is that they did not impose a huge gaudy namesake on the dial. It is a simple, clean Stuckx logo void of any text. Nothing worse that feeling like you’re a mobile billboard for some of these watchmakers.
Lume – (10/10)
As far as the lume goes, they don’t disappoint in this area. Brilliant C3 Luminova makes the dial and bezel shine, the hands literally look like they are lightsabres imposing their power onto the dial to make themselves standout like a Vegas billboard. They even found a way to slap some lume under the bezel between 12 & 4. While understandably not as bright as the indices or bezel markers, it is a nice touch that shows how much effort they put into this piece.
Bezel – (9/10)
While I would have preferred a nice matte bezel to match the whole package of the blasted case and matte dial, the move to go sapphire was solid. When Stuckx decided to move to the upgraded Sapphire bezel I immediately cringed when I saw the pics. I really do not like anything glossy on my watches, I find it cheapens the appearance. However, the sheen of the sapphire, while glossy, really only shows in bright light making for a smashing overall appearance. Bezel has smooth rotation and lines up nicely at 12.
Strap – (7/10)
I really don’t think any watchmaker can win in this department. There is no one utopian strap or strap system for everyone. In fact when I look at the options Stuckx faced, I think they did ok. Trying to decide between 20mm, 22mm, 24mm, fixed or open lugs and then the choice of rubber, nylon, leather combined with Nato, RAF, Zulu, 2pc standard.
The Stuckx strap is soft but sturdy, definitely comfy on the wrist with enough holes to adjust nicely but does feel somewhat cheap. You can tell they put care and effort into designing the straps aesthetics from the stitching colour matched to the respective watch down to the nicely stamped Stuckx logo. Thickness is perfect for comfort and to avoid bulkiness on the wrist. However, the one area that was a real swing and miss for me was the polished hardware against a blasted case. I know it’s a minor detail but imo strap hardware should always match or compliment the case. I do understand economies of scale for the boutique makers result in them having to make these types of decisions. The aftermarket for 24mm Nato/RAF, Zulu straps is somewhat limited in terms of selection compared to the 20mm, 22mm availability. That being said I applaud Stuckx decision to go with the beefier 24mm as opposed to the industry common 20 or 22mm. There is nothing worse than a nice beefy timepiece that is complimented with a dinky little girly 20mm strap. Lastly, while Stuckx did offer a nylon option for an additional fee, I would have preferred to have the choice between leather or nylon or ideally a rubber strap. In my opinion a dive watch should always come with rubber or nylon. I want to be able to jump in the water as soon as I open the package. I love leather on my divers but only when I am wearing it around casually.
Bottom line I don’t know that there was a perfect strap/lug option. Everyone has different preferences and I’m happy they stuck with an outside the box design to keep this a very unique piece.
Packaging/Presentation – (9/10)
Very nicely designed with some thoughtful touches. A convenience flap on the front makes it easy to remove the watchbox from the outer carton. The warranty card is tucked into the lid, nice cushion to hold the watch in place. Lift up the top panel to find a parts bin for additional straps, buckles and tools.
Service – (10/10)
At the time of this writing I have not experienced after-sales service. However, the pre-sales has been nothing short of top-notch. Stuckx does not use the traditional email communication to keep customers informed, bur rather chose to keep us posted thru Facebook. I have never experienced this style of customer updates but it was fantastic. It allowed customers to post pictures as they received watches, questions to be asked and answered and my inbox to be less clogged. One thing for sure is that Stephan busted his balls getting these orders out before Christmas and he was successful. Mine was delivered at 10am Christmas Eve morning. More impressive is that shortly after I received my shipping notification, Stephan sent me a personal email informing me that the alternative strap I ordered with my watch would be follow via regular mail as he shipped the watches from a location other than the shop and only had the stock colour on hand. That’s how you keep customers people. Thanks Stephan!
Bottom Line - (9/10)
A standing ovation please. A fresh new boutique watch company that comes from blood, sweat and tears. A stellar “outside of the box” design and features give customers a one of a kind timepiece that stands up and demands attention on the wrist.
Pros –
24mm lug width
Creative “out of the box” design
Gorgeous fit/finish
Stunning presence on the wrist
Comfortable for a daily wearer
Company communication
Cons –
Polished strap hardware
Should come with choice of leather or nylon
Faux wrist curvature look
Specs (as per Stuckx website)
- Titanium grade 2 lug-less case in blasted finish
- Lug-to-lug 52mm
- 44.8 mm diameter at the top
- 21mm high from case back to sapphire top
- 1000m Water resistance
- Swiss ETA 2824 automatic movement
- C3 Luminova on hands & indices
- Sapphire bezel insert with C3 Luminova markers underneath
- 6mm thick sapphire crystal with AR coating (inside)
- 4mm thick screw-in type case back
- 120 clicks uni-directional bezel
- Leather Zulu/Nato up to 3 mm thickness will fit
- Watch comes in a luxury watch box
- 24 Month warranty
Had a little fun making up some new straps for casual wear. I thought the yellow would prove difficult, but some of the extreme contrasts actually work.
- toxicavenger
- President Tranny
- Posts: 48254
- Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 8:25 am
- Name: HeadDIK
- Location: Colorado Springs
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
Great pics and amazing review. While the watch isn't for me I appreciate all the work he put into it.
Website: http://smallwhitestubbies.com/
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
Good job, I can't write worth a damn, so my hat's off to you.
It would be interesting to hear your 10's. When you write Dial is 9/10 or Wearability is 9/10, what is your 10?
For instance Wearability 10/10 would be Pelagos or Shogun for me....
Also, perhaps a comparison shot next to something pedestrian and common such as Seiko SKX or similar would be beneficial to those who are thinking about picking one of these up and wondering about its size.
Thanks
It would be interesting to hear your 10's. When you write Dial is 9/10 or Wearability is 9/10, what is your 10?
For instance Wearability 10/10 would be Pelagos or Shogun for me....
Also, perhaps a comparison shot next to something pedestrian and common such as Seiko SKX or similar would be beneficial to those who are thinking about picking one of these up and wondering about its size.
Thanks
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
Wearability 9/10 and its as big as my cup of yogurt I ate this morning.
Finish 10/10? Service even though you haven't experienced it a 10/10?
One of the most lol worthy reviews I've seen in a while.
Finish 10/10? Service even though you haven't experienced it a 10/10?
One of the most lol worthy reviews I've seen in a while.
DEATH FROM ABOVE
- streetracer101
- Posts: 8790
- Joined: Tue Nov 15, 2011 6:41 pm
- Name: Mr Shackleford
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
I admittedly didn't read the whole review, but can you elaborate on why it needs to be so tall? The cx military is purpose built and isn't much taller, and its a chrono to boot.
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
I just want to see a watch this big offered with 50m water resistance.
DEATH FROM ABOVE
- greenlightning
- The Dude
- Posts: 3460
- Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2011 2:30 pm
- Name: Kris
- Location: Texas
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
I want you to review my company
- Terpits
- Creepy Tudor Guy
- Posts: 6174
- Joined: Sat Apr 26, 2014 9:06 am
- Name: Peter
- Location: Hill Country TX
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
I am stunned.
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
That was pretty amazing I would give that review a 13 out of 10 though I did not read it.
" The sunshine bores the daylights outta me......"
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
I'll be honest - I stopped reading after this as I questioned the credibility of the rest. Do you mean it is very wearable compared to most watches in general, or very wearable compared to other 27mm watches. I would probably need to modify my wardrobe to wear this.Fit/Wearability – (9/10)
Fantastic! Considering the watch comes in at a towering 27mm tall it wears extremely comfy.
The review does look very thorough and there are nice photos, so i give you credit for content.
- 59yukon01
- 1.21 gigawatts?!
- Posts: 10739
- Joined: Mon Jan 19, 2015 8:49 am
- Name: David
- Location: Louisville, KY
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
To each their own, but that watch is just way too tall for my taste.
- blueradish
- Posts: 130
- Joined: Fri Feb 06, 2015 6:30 pm
- Name: blueradish
- Location: Canada
- Contact:
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
Keep in mind, I did not review this watch with the intention of taking all lifestyles into account. I understand that we all operate on different levels. The review is based on my day-to-day life. Shit, this watch could be a 4/10 for some, 7/10 for others. Take what I wrote and apply it to your lifestyle.
Thanks TAtoxicavenger wrote:Great pics and amazing review. While the watch isn't for me I appreciate all the work he put into it.
Good idea on the side by side. See below compared to my 42mm Helson. There is quite a difference. I have about 60 watches, probably owned well over 200. Not sure I really have a 10/10 for wearability. For example, while my Helson is light and small the crown digs into my wrist. This one gets 9/10 because I recognize the height can be dangerous in terms of banging and although I didn't rate it based on others lifestyle, I understand that this watch has limited wearability. Had I not simply rated it based on my lifestyle, I likely would have given it a 7/10. I respect that many may have suit and tie jobs or be mechanics, etc. These are obviously not situations wear the Stuckx works. However, I rated it for my lifestyle. Short sleeves everyday in an office environment. For example, while my Helson is light and small the crown digs into my wrist.Panerai7 wrote:Good job, I can't write worth a damn, so my hat's off to you.
It would be interesting to hear your 10's. When you write Dial is 9/10 or Wearability is 9/10, what is your 10?
For instance Wearability 10/10 would be Pelagos or Shogun for me....
Also, perhaps a comparison shot next to something pedestrian and common such as Seiko SKX or similar would be beneficial to those who are thinking about picking one of these up and wondering about its size.
Thanks
Great question and definitely one for Stuckx and not me. It may have an actual purpose or could simply be aesthetics.streetracer101 wrote:I admittedly didn't read the whole review, but can you elaborate on why it needs to be so tall? The cx military is purpose built and isn't much taller, and its a chrono to boot.
Thanks man, I didn't rate or review it with any other watch in mind. When I speak of wearability, I take into account many things. Does it annoy me (ie crown dig into wrist), weight, do I notice it throughout the day. What can I say, it's comfy on the wrist for a big watch. Nothing bothered me, nothing hurt, the only reason for the reduction was due to the fact that the height comes into play for knockability. If I wore a dress shirt everyday, I would have rated it lower but then again I probably wouldn't have bought it. My lifestyle is conducive to this type of watch.dnslater wrote:I'll be honest - I stopped reading after this as I questioned the credibility of the rest. Do you mean it is very wearable compared to most watches in general, or very wearable compared to other 27mm watches. I would probably need to modify my wardrobe to wear this.Fit/Wearability – (9/10)
Fantastic! Considering the watch comes in at a towering 27mm tall it wears extremely comfy.
The review does look very thorough and there are nice photos, so i give you credit for content.
- Heuerville
- Posts: 4706
- Joined: Sun Sep 01, 2013 11:09 am
- Name: Stewart
- Location: UK
- Contact:
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
Absurdity 10/10
Stewart - Heuerville & Heuerville Straps
http://heuerville.wordpress.com/heuerville-straps/
"SOB get me a drink"
http://heuerville.wordpress.com/heuerville-straps/
"SOB get me a drink"
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
Insanity 10/10
- streetracer101
- Posts: 8790
- Joined: Tue Nov 15, 2011 6:41 pm
- Name: Mr Shackleford
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
I actually like the dial of this watch. I understand the height is probably more to make a statement, but if it was about 14mm shorter it probably would've been a hit w/the micro brand world.
If this thread did one thing, it got me looking more closely at the brand. Sure, I don't get this model, or the name for that matter, but I do think this model has potential:
If this thread did one thing, it got me looking more closely at the brand. Sure, I don't get this model, or the name for that matter, but I do think this model has potential:
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
Appreciate the review - I was just thinking that I should write a couple more, I do enjoy doing write ups on my thoughts on watches as well.
However, putting a numeric scale is trying to make objective that which is not. It meaningless. I'd definitely omit that. I also stopped reading as soon as I saw that fit/wearability got a 9/10.
If you want to rate things, I would rate it in comparison to other well known watches. This gives people a sense of the watch even if they haven't held the object of review in hand. While still subjective, it is at least within a frame of reference that people can start to grasp.
However, putting a numeric scale is trying to make objective that which is not. It meaningless. I'd definitely omit that. I also stopped reading as soon as I saw that fit/wearability got a 9/10.
If you want to rate things, I would rate it in comparison to other well known watches. This gives people a sense of the watch even if they haven't held the object of review in hand. While still subjective, it is at least within a frame of reference that people can start to grasp.
- mattcantwin
- mattcreatestonsofwatchrelateddrama
- Posts: 18711
- Joined: Wed Dec 02, 2009 3:53 pm
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
I was "struggling" to put my thoughts into words and saw that Matt did it for me.
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
I agree- I like the dial. Different case design- if it was half its size and value priced I would make it a beater.
DEATH FROM ABOVE
- YOHOHO
- Dirty Closet Hinderer Whore
- Posts: 2342
- Joined: Tue Dec 01, 2009 12:14 pm
- Name: Josh
- Location: SoCal
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
Great pics. Not for everyone, but I like it and respect those that aren't confined by current designs. I also like the fact the dial doesn't have a ton of writing and that the co. name is omitted...I prefer logos to names...
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
I'll be the East German judge and give it 4s across the board.
"It's such a fine line between stupid, and clever."
David St. Hubbins
David St. Hubbins
- sinner
- Closet Baller
- Posts: 1484
- Joined: Tue Dec 01, 2009 5:26 pm
- Name: Sum Ting Wong
- Location: Naptown
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
Any benefit from being constructed of grade 2 Ti?
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
You can actually lift your arm to see what time it is?sinner wrote:Any benefit from being constructed of grade 2 Ti?
- 1954Selmer
- Posts: 3593
- Joined: Sun Feb 02, 2014 12:07 pm
- Name: RCA
-
- Posts: 4849
- Joined: Tue Dec 01, 2009 3:47 pm
- Name: John
- Location: CLE
Re: [Review] - Stuckx Rock Diver
Heuerville wrote:Absurdity 10/10
stop your moaning and start making straps for this model Stewart.
"Go forth, my progeny, grab the world by the balls, squeeze hard and shake vigorously." J. Koch (aka "Swedefreak")
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 23 guests