Post
by Isthmus » Mon Jul 18, 2011 9:03 am
Alright lillihood, lets see if I can sum it up for you.
there are three main platforms for smartphones and tablets right now: Android, IOS (what the Iphone uses), and Blackberry. Yes there are other operating systems (such as Windows Phone 7, Symbian, and WebOS, but hardly anybody uses them, so forget about them). Windows might become a player if their deal with Nokia ever yields any product. for now though they are notworth considering.
You obviously no longer want Blackberry (who can blame you) so lets give you the skinny on Android, IOS and Windows.
The first thing to understand is that they are all operating systems. Just like home computers, the hardware is mostly off the shelf and for the most part (though not always) the same suppliers build the guts that most of these phones use, regardless of whose brand is no it. Also some companies (mainly apple and HP and to a lesser degree microsoft), control every aspect of the phone, both in terms of hardware and software. This means that they are able to ensure that all their software and apps designed to work on their phones, work exactly as they want them too, and that stuff is stable and fast at all times. the downer is that most of the companies that do this achieve that stability and functionality by limiting features and locking you out of your phone's internals. In other words, there is very little you can do in terms of customizing the experience or servicing the unit.
The different operating systems basically giev you different levels of control, relative to apps and ability to customize the experience. Here is how I see them:
Windows.
pros: By far the easiest to use of all the smartphone operating systems. It's tile design is made for reading information at a glance.
Cons: Very few phones currently use them. not currently available in tablets. Relatively few apps. ebnvironment is very tightly controlled by microsoft and has almost no custiming. It is pretty muched locked to microsoft for services (search navigation, etc.).
Recommendation: This is an OS for your grandparents or luddites wanting their first smartphone. If you think technology is voodoo magic, then this is for you. If you can still wipe your own ass, then pass.
IOS.
Pros: the oldest of the major smartphone platforms and the one with the most third party developer support. It is also rock solid and super stable. Easy to use (my 3 year old uses my ios devices better then me sometimes). More apps than any other system and the apps almost always work as intended (no system crashes or slow downs). No Malware.
Cons: Apple lock-in (everything goes through apple and works best on apple hardware). NO WIDGETS. No native navigation. Reliance on Itunes for updating data. Proprietary connectors and heavy use of DRM. Now tehering of any kind. No porn.
Recommendation: If you are looking for a platform that is rock solid, stable, and works every single time you turn it on, then look no further. keep in mind that cutomization is limited and there are no widgets. Also you will not be able to service the unit (it is encapsulated and uses proprietary screws that require an apple wrench to open). If you break it or kill the battery on a new model, only apple can fix it. They are also close to the most expensive smartphones on the market.
Android:
Pros: Flexibility. YOu can run android as intended by the manufacturer or customize the crap out of it. If you don't like the desktop environment, then replace it for one that you like. YOu want animated wallpapers, its got them. You want widgets, its got them. want porn, its got it. Want software from a source other than the market, side load from anywere. Android is at it's most basic, a lot like IOS in that it runs right out of the box. However, in manty ways it is much much more, as it allows you to customize the experience quite extensively, allowing you to use the device in a way unique to you. Android is second only to apple in number of apps. Android devices also have removable and upgradeable memory, batteries you can switch yourself and for the most part use off the shelf connectors. Their file system is also not proprietary, which means that it works with any computer system without being tied to a single program (like IOS and Itunes)
Cons: Flexibility. Yes that flexibvility comes with negatives as well. for example the vetting process for apps is nearly as rigorous as it is for ios apps, so it is not uncommon to find an app that simply doesn't run or crashes in some phones, but runs perfectly on others. Also because android is made available for free to manufacturers, they are able to put it in littreally hundreds of different devices. The problem is that not all the devices have the same level of development or the same specs. As a result, as android continues to evolve, older, lower spec devices often find themselves stuck unable to upgrade their operating systems.
Recommendations: android is not difficult, but it does have a learning curve that is a bit greater than on most other phones. because of it's flexibility there is greater in-built instability and possibility for uploading malware apps. On the plus side is supper customizable and allows you to run tons of programs at the same time. It is also available from every carrier. My only recommendation is that you buy the absolute highest end model you can find so as to ensure that future software upgrades don't break it. Also the closest you can get to vanilla android, the greater the chance that you will get upgrade in a timely manner and that the system will remain stable.
There is more to consider and I've left a few things out, but this is generally it. personally I recommend that if you are not afraid to learn a bit about the technology, then android give much more to the user than any other platform, especially when it is used on high end hardware. If what you want is something nearly as powerful, but much more stable and easier to use, then just get an Iphone.
As for android hardware, what you buy is what you get. you can't swap out and upgrade processors on any phone. The best you can do on android is change batteries and swap out memory (which is more than you can do on any other platform BTW). the point is to do your research and choose wisely because the phone you end up buying is the one you'll be living with for a while. If you do decide to go with Android, then I would recommend that you pick something on your network, with a bigger battery and with dual core processors of a minimum 1ghz a piece. I believe there are 1.2ghz dual cores available right now and there will be 1.4ghz dual cores available sometime this fall.
I hope that helps a little.
